25x Conversion Lift for a Legacy Brokerage

First Metropolitan Realty's existing site was decades out of date, lacked mobile responsiveness and had incredibly high bounce rates, leading to lost leads for the brokerage. Across an 8 week sprint, I fully revamped their branding and designed their site into a responsive, optimized experience that increased their site lead conversion by 25x.

25x Conversion Lift for a Legacy Brokerage

Alcohol sales company lost time + revenue digging through excel (20m+ avg.). Across a 6 week sprint I designed the front end of an internal analytics dashboard that unified their spreadsheets into scannable revenue trends, goals, and inventory tracking. Increasing operational efficiency and improving data hunting time by +75%.

01. IMPACT & DELIVERY

How I increased FM Realty's site leads by 2400%

I took my client's site leads from less than 10 leads per month to 175+, and increased their client trust ratings across their 2 target demographics by over 65%. Here is how I did it:

My Role & Deliverables

As a solo designer, I tackled First Metropolitan Realty's complete rebrand and site development by reverse engineering their analytics and user feedback, pinpointing pain points to optimize my client's positioning in Toronto's competitive realtor market against giants like Sotheby's. Using this approach, I delivered an animated, fully responsive site with 20+ screens, and a scalable brand identity system, including a modular logo suite, brand assets and collateral.

Key Metrics

Increased lead conversion by +25x

Improved client trust ratings by over 65%

increased site session duration by 233%

Oversaw a 3x uplift in CTA clicks

Lead Growth

+

25

x

Client Trust Ratings

+

65

%

Client Trust

+

65

%

Session Duration

+

233

%

Session Time

+

233

%

CTA Uplift

+

300

%

Simplified MoSCoW Diagram

This visual captures my MoSCoW approach at a glance: I mapped 50+ ideas from analytics/user feedback to these buckets, focusing 70% effort on Must/Should for 90% lead-gen impact. The full artifact (shared with stakeholders) spans 3 pages with user stories, dependencies, and metrics.

Must-Have

Responsive Layout

Contact / Email Collection

WCAG 2.1 AA: 4:5:1

Should-Have

Animated components

Calendly intergration

Overlay Drop Down Nav

Could Have

AR / Virtual 360 Tours

Mini market trends dashboard

Dark Mode Toggle

Won't-Have

AI Chatbot

Full CRM Integration

Multi-language support

Must-Have

Responsive Layout

Contact / Email Collection

WCAG 2.1 AA: 4:5:1

Should-Have

Animated components

Calendly intergration

Overlay Drop Down Nav

Could Have

AR / Virtual 360 Tours

Mini market trends dashboard

Dark Mode Toggle

Won't-Have

AI Chatbot

Full CRM Integration

Multi-language support

Client Communication

In this solo led rebrand + site project, I achieved incredible results through consistent alignment with the two owners of the brokerage. This consisted of:

Weekly 1hr Zoom Strategy Meetings + Prototype walkthroughs with the Brokerage owners and their team

Bi-Weekly 15-20m validation sessions with FM's realtors

Result: "Julia was thorough, detail-oriented and delivered a site that has achieved more in 6 months than it has in years for our business" - Clara Mione, Owner

02. GOALS & RESEARCH

Why are a new website & rebrand needed?

My client had an outdated, non responsive website that was driving near-zero leads. This made FMR look unprofessional and out of touch despite decades of experience. They needed a modern brand identity and web experience that showcases their expertise and brings in leads.

Research Overview

I began my research by gaining an understanding the core operations of the brokerage, and how their current site and branding are failing them. This included answering the following:

What is my client's unique value proposition and how is their current site/branding failing to convey that?

What does my client's target audience look like, and what are their pain points?

How are FMR's competitors succeeding in this competitive market and how can I differentiate my client sucessfully?

Discovery Methods

Realtor focus group & interviews

Owner interviews

Attention insight heatmap analysis

Competitor audit

Target audience/User interviews

Journey mapping

Admin operations audit

Key Observations

Challenge

Method

Design Opportunity

Design

90% Mobile Bounce

GA4 (pre-redesign)

Sticky nav, micro-interactions, light, seamless UI

Client Trust Gap

20 client interviews (80% cited unreliable feel)

Navy primary palette, Gestalt shapes for brand, high contrast CTAs, Oversized imagery

Low Conversions

0% mobile conversions

Sky blue accents for approachability, more CTAs, homepage email signup

Competition Lag

Competitor audit (10 local rivals w/ 4x traffic)

High contrast ratios, larger images, softer color palette for differentiation, no full image on hero.

Hero Disconnect

GA4 (pre-redesign)

Above-fold peek, hamburger nav to encourage users to scroll

03. PROCESS

How I systematically redesigned FMR

Learn more about how I strategically approached each phase of the design process to optimize site outcomes for my client, decreasing mobile bounce from 90% to 25%.

Learn more about how I methodically tackled each design phase, utilizing iterative testing and design principles to enhance data clarity and overall dashboard efficiency.

  1. Discovery

Kicked off the project with an in depth discovery phase, encompassing focus groups, realtor/stakeholder/user interviews, gaining GA4 analytics insights, auditing their competitors, their operations, and more.

I created three wireframe structures to test information hierarchy and test which visual formats would be the most successful. Through user feedback I determined the following:

  1. Research Synthesis

This phase was all about understanding and analyzing my findings in discovery, identifying pain points, success metrics, user needs, and creating diagrams to help understand which design solutions could solve those pain points and which ones I would implement.

  1. Visual System

The design of the visual system consists of creating the groundwork for the new brand system that would represent FMR as a company. It included typography, iconography, a full logo suite, colour palette, and for the web system, a component library and accessibility guidelines for the colour palette usage.

  1. Design Process

Phase 4 consisted of designing the wireframes for the screens and state variants in Figma, and creating responsive lo-fi and then mid-fi prototypes with rounds of testing throughout (Heatmaps/ AB testing/ Feedback loops).

  1. Development

Development for this project was done in framer, where I created Hi-fi prototypes, and made the site feel alive through the addition of micro-interactions, and scroll animations. Thorough testing was also performed at this stage.

  1. Publishing & Handoff

Once the final prototype was approved, the final stage involved updating the DNS to load the site to it's new domain, double checking load times via lighthouse, performing a client walkthrough for the site, and setting up A/B testing for different CTA variations to optimize conversion for my client.

04. KEY DECISIONS
04. KEY DECISIONS

How my findings fueled key design decisions

Brand Design System

Designed for trust, reliability and professionalism, with a UI focus to target the client's pain points.

M-Form: The logo forms the shape of an M, using pillars that stand for stability and reliability.

Roof Shape: The roofline integrates Gestalt closure, reinforcing realty. (Users noted an increase in visual stability)

Upward Lines: Directional lines signal future-forward thinking (3x+ Millennial Improvement)

Navy Primary: Professional & trustworthy (80%+ boomer approval and increase in perceived trust across users)

Approachable Accent: Added for modern approachability (Users noted more "friendly")

Web Design System

The web system was designed to hit all of my client's pain points and truly optimize the web experience for its users.

Problem: Nav Detracting from Images

Solution: Hamburger Nav

During testing, a regular nav was found to take user attention away from the images/text below. By using a hamburger nav we remove this barrier.

Problem: Millennial Audience Bouncing

Problem: Millennial Bouncing

Solution: Scroll Animations

Our younger target audience was found to have higher bounce rates from static sites, so I implemented scroll animations.

Problem: Low High-Intent Lead Capture

Problem: Low Lead Capture

Solution: Homepage Email Signup

Solution: Email Signup

I used a homepage email signup with a CTA style header to encourage user signups and capture high intent leads early.

Problem: Low Buyer Trust

Solution: Oversized Imagery

During testing, I found that smaller images reduced trust with buyers. By increasing image size, we saw a significant increase in buyer trust metrics.

Problem: Hero to Listings Disconnect

Solution: Above-Fold Peek

The previous site had issues getting users to scroll. So I implemented a curiosity hook to encourage users to keep scrolling using an above the fold peek.

Problem: Mobile Scroll Fatigue

Solution: Sticky Scroll Nav

More than 60% of clients were found to use the site through mobile. To limit mobile scroll fatigue, I implemented a sticky scroll nav.

Problem: Readability in Older Users

Solution: Light UI

My testing found that older users are more familiar with light UI. So I implemented a light UI with 4:5:1 contrast to capture leads dark realty sites missed.

Problem: Low Site Conversions

Solution: More CTA's

The previous site lacked strong CTA's, which are vital in lead capture and conversion. I implemented more CTA's and stronger CTA's throughout the site.

05. SPRINT RETROSPECTIVE

Key learnings & next steps

Key Learnings

Throughout the design of this website, I took home a few key learnings:

Throughout the design of this website, I took home a few key learnings:

Older users show a 20% preference for light UIs due to historical familiarity from pre-2018 desktop/web defaults, reducing cognitive load.

Iterative prioritization (Must/Should/Could/Won't) was key in picking essential features for this 4 page site.

Having more frequent feedback loops with realtors, stakeholders and users validated assumptions early, saving redesign costs later on.

Winning Moments

2400% Lead Surge: Site revamp skyrocketed leads 6 months post launch from <10 to >175.

Incredible Feedback: Owners raved post-presentation, crediting visuals for huge recent success after years of stagnant growth.

Huge Uplift+: Dropped mobile bounce 90%→25%, boosted lead conversion +25x, improved client trust +65%, increased session duration 233%, and oversaw a 3x uplift in CTA clicks.

Next Steps

I truly enjoyed making this site and rebrand come to life, watching my client's conversion metrics increase so much has been so rewarding. Looking ahead, I'm excited to weave all that I've learned from this project into fresh challenges, and keep pushing what thoughtful UI/UX can do!!

Interested in learning more?

Check out my case study on the end to end design of an internal sales analytics dashboard here:

6min Read

Designing an Internal Sales Analytics Dashboard

Let's Connect!

Let's Connect!